by Alan Thornhill
After a long, often emotional debate, the House of Representatives tonight passed a private member’s bill, designed to stop asylum seekers boarding leaky boats, to come to Australia.
The bill which Rob Oakeshott put up as a possible compromise, proposes offshore processing of asylum seekers both in Malaysia and on Nauru.
The government supported the bill.
The Opposition sought an amendment, excluding Malaysia.
The six hour debate was dominated, though, by the news that a second asylum seeker boat had capsized off Christmas Island, just days after another, which also capsized, with loss of perhaps 90 lives.
The Prime Minister Julia Gillard said 125 people had been rescued from the second boat, which is thought to have been carrying up to 150 asylum seekers.
However only one death had been confirmed, at the time of writing.
The final vote on the Oakeshott bill was 74-72.
The opposition had fought hard to amend the bill, to block processing in Malaysia, under an agreement with that country, which the Opposition Leader described as “a dud deal.”
Mr Abbott declared processing in Malaysia deal would strip away “protections” from asylum seekers, sent to that country.
“Their standards are not our standards,” he said.
But the opposition’s amendment was defeated.
The Oakeshott bill will go to the Senate tomorrow (Thursday), with one amendment.
That small, but successful, moved by a Tasmanian Independent Andrew Wilkie, inserted a 12 month “sunset clause” in the bill.
This means that if the bill becomes law, it would automatically lapse after 12 months.
The issues would then have to be debated again.
However that is unlikely.
That’s because the Oakeshott bill faces almost certain defeat tomorrow in the Senate.
Earlier in the day, some 40 MPs, from all sides in Parliament, had met privately, hoping to find a practical solution to the asylum seeker issue.
But that has not yet emerged, even though there was some movement, on both government and opposition stands.
Julia Gillard’s announcement, that the government would be prepared to re-open a processing facility on Nauru, was meant to attract Opposition support for the Oakeshott bill.
However Tony Abbott said the Coalition would be prepared to lift Australia’s refugee and humanitarian intake to 20,000 a year, over three years, if the Malaysia agreement was scrapped.
But that didn’t happen, either.
This means that the government and opposition are still at odds, over what should be done, to prevent further asylum seeker deaths at sea.
Alan Thornhill is a parliamentary press gallery journalist.
Private Briefing is updated daily with Australian personal finance news, analysis, and commentary.
Monday December 9
Thai Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra says she will dissolve parliament and call an election, after sustained protests in the capital, Bangkok.
Parliament has passed laws to abolish the debt ceiling just three days before the Government said the nation’s books would hit the cap of $300 billion.
The Dow Jones index rose 198.69 points (Friday, New York time) to 16,020.20
Tony Abbott’s bills to repeal the carbon tax face defeat in the Senate this week, raising the spectre of a double dissolution
|Aud To Usd||0.9086||N/A||N/A|
|Bhp Blt Fpo||36.770||+0.020||+0.05%|
|Nat. Bank Fpo||33.170||-0.300||-0.90%|
|Qbe Insur. Fpo||12.000||-3.450||-22.33%|
The News This Week
- Hockey welcomes decision on debt ceiling
- Processing at Ranger suspended
- Downturn looming:Stevens
- Retirement:our changing ways
- Homes:what we are building
- Holden sets its price
- The PM’s final appeal
- Mining boom widens the gaps
- Hockey stopping cheques
- Robb hails trade breakthrough
- PM to visit South Africa to honour Nelson Mandela
- Big fuel discounts to end
- Holden:What now?
- Qantas “under pressure” PM
- PM announces free trade agreement with the Republic of Korea
- Airlines (81)
- Banking (2574)
- Business (2690)
- Communications (58)
- crime (15)
- Disaster (119)
- Economics (2662)
- education (1)
- Environment (130)
- Financial advice (2415)
- Health (102)
- Housing (711)
- Inflation (528)
- Insurance (107)
- Investment (2193)
- Markets (1992)
- Media (133)
- medical (42)
- mining (269)
- pay (111)
- Politics (2728)
- population (166)
- Regulation (1033)
- retirement (87)
- rural (15)
- Rural australia (113)
- Security (23)
- Social security (256)
- Superannuation (235)
- Tax (404)
- The latest (129)
- Trade (742)
- Uncategorized (391)